U.S. 2024 Election: SEC Chair Gensler’s Future on the Line

U.S. 2024 Election: SEC Chair Genslers Future on the Line

• Genslers SEC chair role faces an uncertain future based on the 2024 election outcome.
• Legal precedents limit direct removal of SEC chair, complicating leadership shifts.
• Trump or Harris may leverage alternative strategies to adjust SECs leadership.

As the nation watches the results of today‘s U.S. presidential election, the future leadership of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) hangs in the balance. Led by Chairman Gary Gensler since 2021, the SEC has received both praise and criticism for its recent policy directions. A new presidential administration, whether led by Donald Trump or Kamala Harris, could bring notable changes to the SEC’s top leadership.

If former President Donald Trump returns to office, he may look to replace or demote Gensler, potentially by appointing another SEC commissioner, such as Hester Peirce or Mark Uyeda, as acting chair. On the other hand, if Vice President Kamala Harris takes office, her stance on Genslers position remains uncertain. While some have pressured Harris to remove Gensler, her administration could also choose to keep him, especially if a Republican-led Senate resists potential nominees.

Can the President Remove the SEC Chair？

Removing the SEC Chair is not as straightforward as it may seem. A 1935 Supreme Court case, Humphrey‘s Executor, set a precedent that restricts the president’s power to remove commissioners from independent agencies like the SEC without cause.

A 1935 Supreme Court case (Humphrey's Executor) protected an FTC commissioner from presidential removal. It didn't address the SEC, but the way the two commissions work and their independence from the executive branch is similar (2/3)

— Dave Michaels (@davidamichaels) November 5, 2024

This ruling applied to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) but has since influenced how the SEC and other similar regulatory bodies are treated. Therefore, any president, whether Trump or Harris, would likely face legal challenges if they sought to directly dismiss Gensler.

Although this case didnt specifically address the SEC, it supports the idea of independence for similar regulatory commissions. This means that even if a new president wanted to remove Gensler as chair, Gensler could stay on as an SEC commissioner until 2026, maintaining a degree of influence over decisions until a successor is confirmed. Such scenarios highlight the potential complexities involved in a leadership transition at the SEC.

What Each Candidates Win Could Mean for the SEC

In the event of a Trump win, he might take steps to demote Gensler, possibly appointing Commissioners Hester Peirce or Mark Uyeda as acting chair. Trumps administration could view this as a way to quickly shift the SECs focus, aligning more closely with Republican values. However, Gensler could choose to remain as a commissioner through 2026, maintaining some influence over SEC decisions.

Read also: Trumps Pro-Crypto Shift Drives Bitcoin Surge and Memecoin Frenzy in 2024 Election

If Harris prevails, her approach to Gensler‘s leadership remains less predictable. Despite some calls to replace Gensler, she has yet to clarify her views on his performance. If a Republican-controlled Senate blocks any new SEC chair nominees, Harris might retain Gensler to avoid immediate friction with Congress. This move could delay changes to SEC policy, allowing Gensler to continue shaping the agency’s direction.